Cleveland council race features unique candidate

6

CLEVELAND - Volunteers are going house to house in this hard-hit city's West Side, getting out the vote for a candidate who they believe will "shake things up" and bring change to a neighborhood pockmarked with abandoned houses and torn up streets.
It is one of the most intriguing of several hot races around the country that will be decided on Tuesday.

Rick Nagin, a longtime resident of Cleveland's Ward 14, is in a runoff to represent the ward in the City Council. Nagin has deep roots in the ward. He and his wife Ann raised their two daughters there. His resume gives his experience as an AFL-CIO labor candidate school graduate, and the fact he is fluent in Spanish, priority over his PhD from Rockefeller University. Nagin is a member of the Communications Workers of America and a delegate to the Cleveland Central Labor Council. He is seen as the labor candidate, endorsed by the local AFL-CIO and labor's champion Rep. Dennis Kucinich, along with a number of local unions.

Nagin also writes for this newspaper, and makes no bones about the fact that he believes socialism is a better way to organize society than the dog-eat-dog, profit before people way of capitalism.

Nagin has had to fend off red-baiting from his opponent and various other sources. He scored an upset by coming in second in the September primary, putting him into the Nov. 4 runoff against Ward 15 councilman Brian Cummins, whose seat was eliminated by redistricting. Some of Nagin's unsuccessful primary opponents have joined Cummins in pushing the red scare line.

But such an approach may not get too far in Ward 14, where people often feel abandoned by a city that is in deep budget crisis. Many see Nagin as the kind of outsider who can "shake things up," as one Vietnam veteran put it.

A walk through the ward shows that "Nagin For The People" signs dominate. It's this support along with Nagin's political views and independence that has garnered national attention, including a special segment on CNN.

The ward is about 40 percent white, including many who have their roots in Appalachia, and 40 percent Puerto Rican, with a growing African American population. Every family there likely can trace their local history to a relative who came to Cleveland for the jobs in steel, auto and other industries.

These days, Cleveland has made national news for its foreclosure rates.

In this working-class community, many know Nagin as a champion of the working-class and the downtrodden. He has had a long relationship with the Puerto Rican community, serving for over seven years as assistant to the first Puerto Rican councilman. He has worked closely with several Hispanic social clubs, and was a volunteer Little League baseball coach.

Cummins on the other hand is seen as championing the small but influential professional grouping in the ward.

Cleveland is one of several cities holding mayoral and council elections this year, joined by Detroit, Atlanta, New York City, Houston, Pittsburgh and Boston. Votes on same-sex marriage are happening in Maine and Washington.

Two big governor races in New Jersey and Virginia are capturing the headlines, as they are being portrayed as a referendum on President Obama. The incumbent New Jersey Democrat, Jon Corzine, faces a tough race against Republican challenger Chris Christie and independent Chris Daggett. In Virginia, a state Obama won in 2008, the first time a Democrat won it since 1964, Republican Robert McDonnell has a sizeable lead in the pre-election polls over Democrat R. Creigh Deeds. Virginia's popular sitting governor, Tim Kaine, is not in the race.

New York's 23rd Congressional District, a traditional Republican area, has garnered much national attention with its special election. What started as a three-way race between Democrat William Owens, Republican Dierdre Scozzafava and Conservative Douglas Hoffman has become a two-way race and something of a political bloodbath between extreme right-wingers and more moderate Republicans. Scozzafava dropped out after a battery of far-right Republicans endorsed Hoffman. Scozzafava is conservative but socially liberal on some issues, a no-no for the Limbaugh/Beck/Palin brand of Republicans. Scozzafava has now endorsed Democrat Owens. Scozzafava's husband, Ronald McDougall, is the president of the Central Trades and Labor Council in the area, and is campaigning for Owen.

Polls have shown the two candidates nearly even in the district, which has about 45,000 more registered Republicans than Democrats.

 

Post your comment

Comments


  • Brian Cummins won the election with a 12% margin; 1,467 votes (56%) to Rick Nagin’s 1,162 votes (44%).

    The "Nagin For The People" signs that dominated in the ward were widely reported and many confirmed to be placed in people’s properties without permission or by aggressive tactics. A common refrain in the community was that “yard signs don’t vote, people do.” The election results confirmed this.

    Although there was an un-claimed red-baiting piece put out by an anonymous entity right before the primary election, the Cummins campaign brought up the issue in two pieces for the general election. Those pieces brought up Rick Nagin’s affiliations and work record with CPUSA in a comparison of professional experience to Cummins.

    Cummins, as described in the article above as “seen as championing the small but influential professional grouping in the ward”, has a record of service to the community and to under-served people internationally. He served in various capacities with the U. S. Peace Corps for nine years, has championed citizens groups in Cleveland and has stood-up against big business and the region’s corrupt politics.

    This was the first in nine elections that Rick Nagin won an election – the primary. He clearly ran an excellent campaign and worked hard.

    The Cummins campaign worked equally hard and ran a very professional campaign.

    In a comparison of campaigns, Nagin actually came out with the most blatant attack piece, calling Cummins a “loner”, “un-trust worthy” and “erratic”. He did so ironically calling voters to “REJECT Dirty Politics”.

    Nagin resorted to this type of campaigning, after the Cummins Campaign began their general election campaign comparing the candidate’s professional records.

    Nagin’s campaign only referred to his seven years of working as a Council Aid and to several political campaigns when describing his professional background. There was never a mention of his almost twenty years of work as the Chairman of the Ohio Communist Party,

    It seems disingenuous for Nagin and his supporters to claim red-baiting tactics were used when he himself did not explain his own professional affiliations and his opponent set-out to do so to inform voters. Even more so, as his campaign went on the attack with the most divisive and negative piece of the general election.

    In an open, public election, a candidate can not expect to be able to hide, or down-play there personal, political and professional experiences. They also cannot realistically claim foul when an opponent accurately presents this information to the public.


    References:

    http://naginforcouncil.com

    http://briancummins.us

    Cleveland council candidate Rick Nagin eschews communist tag
    By Henry J. Gomez, The Plain Dealer, September 28, 2009
    http://blog.cleveland.com/metro/2009/09/cleveland_council_candidate_ri.html

    Posted by IndependentPolitics, 11/15/2009 10:55am (4 months ago)

  • Nice run, Rick! You've done us all proud...

    Posted by Daniel Frontino Elash, 11/04/2009 2:33am (5 months ago)

  • Cleveland Council Ward 14

    17 of 17 precincts reported.

    BRIAN CUMMINS 1467

    RICK NAGIN 1162


    Submission from Marvin Wells cleveland

    Posted by Marvin Wells, 11/04/2009 1:33am (5 months ago)

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments