Of lynch mobs and lawsuits, immigration reform today

As the summer marches on, the possibility that a comprehensive immigration reform law be passed before the November elections is more and more problematic. The Republican Party has decided to go into full lynch-mob mode against the nation's immigrant communities. While on Tuesday, July 6, the U.S. Justice Department filed a lawsuit against the State of Arizona, challenging the constitutionality of SB 1070, a controversial anti-immigrant law.

In its suit, the Justice Department asks that SB 1070 be declared unconstitutional. The suit alleges that 1070 violates the "Supremacy Clause" of the U.S. Constitution, whereby the matter of immigration is seen as an exclusively a federal preserve, and the "Commerce Clause" because it will have the impact of impeding movement of legal non-citizens and citizens across state boundaries. The suit does not defend the rights of undocumented immigrants, but does bring up the issue of racial profiling.

Arizona's Republican Governor Janet Brewer immediately denounced the suit as pandering to Latinos, signaling that in Arizona and nationally, this will become grist for the mills of election-year demagogy.

When President Obama came to office, immigrants' rights activists were anxious for him to move fast in crafting a comprehensive immigration reform and pushing it through Congress. Their motive for haste was the realistic fear that the nearer the country got to the November 2010 midterm elections, the harder it would be to round up even Democratic votes for such a measure, because the right would surely try to accuse them of being "soft on illegals."

Some activists were worried by a pre-election statement by Rahm Emmanuel, now President Obama's Chief of Staff, that he would prefer the whole issue be deferred to the year 2013 so that it would not interfere with the 2012 reelection campaign. So there has been pressure to act from day one.

The immigrants' rights movement continues to organize marches, protests and civil disobedience, now demanding that if no reform is going to be passed, the government at least suspend mass deportations, which have not diminished under Obama.  

In his speech last week, President Obama seemed to close the door on this, on the grounds that to do so would be unfair to people who have been waiting in "line" for legal resident visas. 

The problem is that people come here without papers because they have no chance of getting a visa. The U.S. government simply has not been handing out permanent resident visas to grain farmers from central Mexico or rice farmers from Haiti who have been displaced by corporate globalization in agriculture. If there is a line, these people have been excluded from it by their poverty.

There is very limited movement in Congress on immigration. There is a viable bill in the House of Representatives, HR 4321, which has 102 cosponsors, mostly from the Black, Hispanic, Asian-Pacific and Progressive Caucuses. But 218 votes are needed for a bill to pass the House and, although the Democrats have a big majority, right wing "Blue Dog" Democrats are staying away from the issue or have even joined the immigrant-bashers.

A Senate bill promised by Charles Schumer, D-N.Y., and pushed by President Obama in his speech last week has not yet materialized. Earlier House Speaker Nancy Pelosi had said she would not move legislation in the House until the Senate moved first, and both Senator Harry Reid, D-Nev., and the White House have called for the Republicans to make the first move. However, it appears that the Republicans have decided not to support immigration reform this year at all.

Meanwhile, the ghosts of Lester Maddox and George Wallace are haunting the national debate. Outrageous racist accusations are made in the media against Mexican and other Latino immigrants. Immigrants are caste as the collective bogeyman, to keep Latino voter turnout down and to scare the Democrats into backing away from one of the key demands coming out of their own base.

As many as 20 other states are said to be thinking of legislation similar to Arizona's SB 1070 law, which criminalizes undocumented immigrants and both authorizes and potentially forces (through citizen lawsuits) state and local police to demand the immigration status of people they question for other offenses.

Last month Fremont, Nebraska made it illegal to hire or rent to undocumented immigrants. And the federal government's own 287 g program, which trains and deputizes local police to do immigration work, has been expanded to new communities under Secretary of Homeland Security Janet Napolitano, leading to widespread complaints.

Things could get worse, unless the mobilization at the grassroots by immigrants' rights organizations and their labor, community and religious allies can reach new levels of intensity and breadth.


Post your comment

Comments are moderated. See guidelines here.


  • Wether america needs these illegals or not, the immigration reform has to be now!!!.the Americans can't just keep allowing people to come to your country illegally. As long as America does not fix the legal channel to allow people in there will be illegal immigration, like it or not that's a reality. Illegals have to pay a huge fine to gain citizenship. It needs to be done now in 2010 or the Obama admin will lose credibility. No point of criticising Obama 's suggestion and yet we have no solution. Employers who employ illegals should be punished severely .

    Posted by Francis, 07/11/2010 4:52pm (5 years ago)

  • Lucia Cunha said: "We have the jobs Americans don't want(landscaping, housekeeping, babysitting, dishwashers...), so lets give them to the poor who want them!!! Doing this we are helping our society and people from other countries who doesn't want to live a miserable life."

    Many millions of Americans scrape by doing exactly those kinds of jobs. I personally know plenty who do.

    What do you think happens to them, when they lose their livelihood to a flood of cheap labor?

    Not your problem?

    I understand. I feel the same way about SB 1070: it's not my problem, either.

    Posted by Trailer Trash, 07/09/2010 11:42pm (5 years ago)

  • I totally agree with this article! If there is illegal immigration in this country it's just because of it's broken immigration system. People come here illegal because they cannot get a visa, and this happens just because they are poor, low skill workers. The rich can get a visa at anytime. What a iniquity!!! there are low skill jobs in this country, at least there were before the economic crises took place, and the people from other countries know that, and they want to come here to be part of the american dream and help this society, but they never get to get a visa! This status quo doesn't make any sense!!! If the republicans and democratic want to fix this problem they need to start an immigration reform that allow people to come here legally. With this mentality they will put an end to this problem and also they will help those who want to make poverty history. We have the jobs Americans don't want(landscaping, housekeeping, babysitting, dishwashers...), so lets give them to the poor who want them!!! Doing this we are helping our society and people from other countries who doesn't want to live a miserable life.

    Posted by lucia Cunha , 07/09/2010 10:32pm (5 years ago)

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments